Please note this post may contain an affiliate link
I am a perfectionist.
The downside of being a perfectionist is that I will not do something if I know I will not be perfect at it. The thinking goes along the line of … if I can’t do it perfectly, why bother in the first place?
I also struggle if it doesn’t come to me easily ie if I can’t be perfect at it straight away, chances are I will give up.
Stupid, isn’t it? I understand that ‘practice makes perfect’. But somehow I always judge myself for not getting something right the first time. My friends often tell me that I am very hard on myself.
But I have struggled with this all my life. I am getting better, I think.
I tell myself that sometimes good enough is good enough and there is no need to strive for perfection in everything.
Tracking my expenses is one of those things.
It doesn’t take much to derail me. Or distract me.
I closed one credit card at the end of May (to avoid the annual fee – the first year was free) and carelessly did not note the transactions left. Once I closed the credit card, I could no longer access my phone app. Trying to get the final statement was taking forever via snail mail. And that was all it took to interrupt my habit of recording my expenses.
There was also the end of my stressful job plus planning to travel for five and a half weeks from July. It was just a very tumultuous time overall; routines went out the door. And the recording of my expenses did not seem very important and fell through the cracks.
By the time I returned from my holidays, I was really behind – three and a half months behind! I am now thinking – it’s been so long, what’s the point?
The last time I struggled with tracking my expenses was last year, after my holiday in Uluru. So I do have ‘form’ in this area – holidays disrupt my routine. Or is it guilt that I perhaps may have spent more than I should have?!
Getting back to my 'why'
I remind myself that the whole point in tracking my expenses is to indicate if I am on the right path to achieving Financial Independence (FI). Have I veered off the path? Am I on the edge of a cliff, about to fall off? Or perhaps I am cruising along in the middle of the path, with the wind behind my back.
Knowing how much I spend is just as important as knowing how much I earn and how much I invest. It is part of a three way ‘equation’. In fact I would argue that knowing how much I spend is more important.
If I am not aware of how much I spend and happily spend without limits, I will need to earn more and invest more to keep up with the spending. It is a vicious cycle. And tiring.
Also, as I manually enter the receipts, line by line, I am reminded of what I bought and why I bought it in the first place. And sometimes I discover hidden charges like the surcharge for using my credit card at the butcher.
I can make lots of excuses – I am just not that frugal, I struggle with frugality, I love my travels, it is such a chore, blah blah blah. But at the end of the day, it’s a cop out.
Knowing what my financial situation is, good or bad is better than not knowing at all. Burying my head in the sand is not a solution.
Getting back on track ...
Another bad habit I have which is related to wanting to be perfect all the time is I let missing a session be the end of that practice.
After reading Atomic Habits by James Clear (read my review here), I know that I should not miss twice in any habit I am trying to build.
So I grit my teeth and spend a whole weekend entering four months’ worth of receipts into my tracking app. And vow never, ever to let it get this bad!
It is time to return to my habit of entering receipts every Sunday night, while watching TV.
The result is in ...
Ok … a word (or paragraph) about my savings rate. I choose to calculate my savings rate from my take home pay only, as it is much easier to do.
All my working life, I only look at what I get to keep from my gross salary. Anything the Government takes first is irrelevant to me. That money is lost to me. I can only use the net amount after taxes. Umm ..most of the time, I never really know what my gross income is – only a number I look at when filling my annual tax return. But I always know what my take home pay is.
I know there are various methods of calculating savings rate – eg add gross salary, investment income, side hustle income; deduct taxes, contribution to superannuation (retirement account), etc – my head is spinning already. And there are advantages and disadvantages of using these methods.
But I am a simple girl and at the end of the day, I am only comparing my savings rates with myself ie month on month or year vs year. I am not interested in comparing with someone else’s figure as their situation may be quite different from mine. The important thing is that I am aware of what I spend my money on and make sure that it is aligned with my values.
Aussie HIFIRE has a very good article on exactly this – They’ve Always Been Faster – why it’s hard to compare your savings rate to someone else’s.
So, for the record, I do salary sacrifice into superannuation. That is, I contribute an additional amount pre tax on top of my employer’s compulsory 9.5% contribution. And that figure is ignored in my savings rate.
My 2019 results are as follows:
My average savings rate for nine months to date is 37.7% – it doesn’t look like I can reach my goal of 50% this calendar year. Sigh!
This post is about getting back on track after I’ve skidded off it. Specifically, the track of recording my expenses.
Life is always happening. It is ok to fall off the track but it is important to get back on it again if that still aligns with our purpose or goal. Getting back on track in itself is an achievement.
Now that I am monitoring my expenses once again, it is time to reassess and decide what I can or can’t live with; whether my expenses align with my values.
And most importantly, my mind is at peace knowing I am back in charge of my money – I can tell it where to go, rather than being its slave.
Getting back on track feels wonderful!
10 Replies to “Getting back on track – monitoring my expenses”
When I don’t have time to track our spending for a while, I feel a bit lost and even anxious. As you say, it feels wonderful to get back on track!
Just bringing more mindfulness to your spending does wonders to bring up the savings rate. You may surprise yourself and reach the 50% after all! 🤞
Mindfulness is the key word here! Thanks for the encouragement – much appreciated, Chrissy 🙂
Thanks very much for the mention!
It’s interesting to see the different ways that people go about recording their expenses. I only do it every 6 months and track my savings rate at that time as well, because my income and expenses can be lumpy I think I’d find it too much of an emotional rollercoaster to track it on a monthly basis.
It’s great to hear that you’re back on track now with keeping a record of our expenses, hopefully a few months of minimal spending and you can get close to your savings rate target as well!
You are welcome!
You are right about the emotional roller coaster – the feeling of elation one month then disappointment if it’s a spendy month; but as long as I know why it was a spendy month and can justify the expenses then I’m ok – better to be aware then not.
Don’t stress too much about falling off the bandwagon. We’re all human – stuff happens 🙂
TBH I used to worry about doing monthly savings rates – but then I realised something. They’re going to fluctuate a lot. Especially in the months where we have huge expenses – when the rates, insurance, and all of that stuff is due.
Nowadays I run everything through my credit card, and at the end of the month, I download everything into an app which helps categorise them for me. I do my savings rate check every 6 months, which helps to smooth things out a little bit.
Averaging the percentages might not give you an accurate view of what the 9 month actual savings rate is. Especially if you have monthly fluctuating incomes and expenses. If you do the calc using totals of income and totals of all expenses, that will be your actual savings rate.
That’s true – each month will fluctuate. To me the numbers are a guide and I like to do them monthly just to be aware of the situation and I have time to adjust if need be.
Good point on averaging the monthly percentages – just did the calculation using the nine months’ total of income and expenses as you suggested – 38% so pretty similar. I will do both in future – thanks for the tip!
I see in your linked post you track your expenses using TRACKMySPEND.
Have you ever tried Pocketsmith?
I refuse to hand over my bank details to any of these anonymous websites too. But Pocketsmith let’s you import Excel sheets with your transactions while still outputting all the pretty graphs and stats. So I log into my credit card/bank website myself, copy the transactions into Excel, then upload that into Pocketsmith.
Anyway take a look if you are interested, I am not affiliated with them, just a satisfied user.
Thanks, ETF Bloke! What a coincidence – I have just started trialing Pocketsmith – very early days yet
I’m with you there! I’ve been “trying” to get back on track to track my expenses but keep getting derailed too. Usually, it’s by a succession of unexpected expenses, or just getting really busy. And yes, some of it is even knowing I’m spending more than I’m bringing in, so seeing it right in front of me is confronting. Good for you for entering in 4 months worth of expenses! I should at least TRY and do that for Oct!
Haha, good luck! I must admit I do feel a lot better when I’ve done it – good or bad, at least I know how I’m tracking for the month and adjust if I have to